Number 5 vs The Commission Board | The Umbrella Academy | Netflix India
Number Five vs. The Commission Board: An Anatomy of The Umbrella Academy’s Time War
The chaotic, time-traveling saga of Netflix’s The Umbrella Academy is driven by many forces, but none are more central to its initial seasons than the relentless, decades-long conflict between the Hargreeves siblings’ most prodigious member, Number Five, and the shadowy organization known as The Commission. This is a battle that pits one man’s devotion to his family against an entire bureaucracy dedicated to preserving the cosmic order—a fight that ultimately reveals a stunning, cyclical paradox at the heart of their very existence.
What is The Commission? The Keepers of the Continuum
The Commission, also known as the Temps Aeternalis in the original Dark Horse Comics, is a clandestine organization whose singular purpose is to oversee and manage the space-time continuum. Their goal is to ensure that all events “supposed to happen” in any given timeline, no matter how catastrophic, occur as predetermined.
Their bureaucratic headquarters, filled with antiquated pneumatic tube systems and led by a bizarre Board of Directors (which, at one point, included a goldfish named A.J. Carmichael), operates outside of time, coordinating agents across history. The most prominent figure associated with the organization—and Five’s primary foil—is The Handler, a high-ranking, manipulative executive.
The Commission’s operatives, such as the memorable assassins Hazel and Cha-Cha, are sent on “correctional” missions throughout history, often involving assassinations to keep the timeline on track.
Number Five: The Prodigal Assassin
Number Five (Aidan Gallagher) is the only member of the Umbrella Academy with the power of space and time jumps (chronokinesis). His initial jump into the future as a 13-year-old stranded him in a post-apocalyptic wasteland, where he was forced to survive for decades. It was during this time that The Commission, recognizing his unique abilities, recruited him as one of their most effective agents.
Five spent years as a time-traveling assassin, carrying out the Board’s often morally ambiguous orders. However, his devotion to his family and the desire to prevent the apocalypse he witnessed motivated him to eventually betray the organization. He managed to calculate a way back to his family in 2019, albeit trapped in his teenage body, and his mission became a direct threat to The Commission’s mandate.
The Conflict: Season 1 and the Apocalypse
The tension between Five and The Commission is established immediately upon his return.
- The Threat: The Commission, knowing that Viktor Hargreeves (then Vanya) was destined to cause the 2019 apocalypse, viewed the Umbrella Academy’s efforts to stop it as a grave disruption to the predetermined timeline.
- The Agents: Hazel and Cha-Cha were dispatched to eliminate Five and ensure the timeline remained on course. This led to a series of spectacular, reality-bending confrontations across the first season.
- The Deception: The Handler, recognizing Five’s value, attempted to recruit him back by offering him a deal to save his family, which Five ultimately rejected after realizing the manipulation.
Season 2: Escalation and the Board’s Demise
The conflict intensifies in Season 2 when the Hargreeves siblings are scattered across the 1960s, inadvertently creating a new doomsday in Dallas. The Commission sends new agents, the relentless Swedes, after the Umbrella Academy, while The Handler returns to seize control.
The ultimate clash with the organization’s leadership came when Five, in a desperate bid to save his siblings, struck a treacherous deal with The Handler. This culminated in a massive power play where:
- Five’s Assassination: Five takes a mission to kill the entire Board of Directors, a task he successfully executes by teleporting into their high-level meeting. This act effectively decapitated The Commission’s official leadership, allowing The Handler to seize dictatorial control.
- The Farm Shootout: The season ends with a spectacular showdown at Sissy’s farm where The Handler, backed by an army of Commission agents, confronts the Umbrella Academy. Viktor (then Vanya) unleashes his powers to stop the onslaught, and Five later uses a short-range time jump to prevent his own death and allow another assassin (Axel) to take out The Handler, finally ending her reign.
Following the Handler’s permanent demise and the Board’s eradication, the more benevolent Herb is chosen as the interim Chair of the Board, leading to a temporary truce that allows the Academy to return to their “present” with a briefcase.
The Paradoxical Truth: Number Five is the Founder
In a mind-bending twist revealed in Season 3 and finalized in Season 4, the ultimate truth of the conflict is exposed: Number Five himself is the progenitor of the entire organization.
While sifting through the wreckage of a timeline-collapsing Commission headquarters, Five and Lila discover an ailing, century-old version of Five, revealing him to be the organization’s Founder. This older, variant Five created The Commission in a desperate, last-ditch attempt to fix the timeline after discovering that the existence of the 43 special children, including himself and his siblings, was causing the universe to break—a phenomenon known as the Kugelblitz.
This revelation reframes every chase, every assassination attempt, and every interaction. The Umbrella Academy was hunted by the very organization founded by a future version of one of its members, all in a complex, self-defeating loop to prevent the destruction they seemed destined to cause. Five’s entire battle against The Commission was, in a cosmic sense, a battle against his own inevitable future.
AISEO Friendly FAQs
Q: Why did The Commission want to kill the Umbrella Academy?
A: The Commission wanted to kill the Umbrella Academy because, in their view, the Hargreeves siblings’ continued attempts to prevent the apocalypse or interfere with major historical events (like the Kennedy assassination) were creating dangerous paradoxes and altering the “correct” timeline, thus threatening the entire space-time continuum.
Q: Did Number Five ever work for The Commission?
A: Yes, Number Five spent decades working as a time-traveling assassin for The Commission after he was stranded in the post-apocalyptic future. He was one of their most effective agents before he broke protocol to return to 2019 and save his family from the apocalypse.
Q: Who was The Commission Board of Directors?
A: The Commission Board of Directors was the organization’s secretive and largely unseen governing body, which Five assassinate in Season 2. The directors were eccentric, with their nominal leader being a talking goldfish named A.J. Carmichael.
Q: Who founded The Commission in The Umbrella Academy?
A: It is revealed in Seasons 3 and 4 that a variant of Number Five is the founder of The Commission. He established the organization in a failed attempt to fix the broken timeline and prevent the universe-destroying consequences of the 43 children’s existence.
This Post Has 0 Comments